Two For Tuesday: Shelley Fabares and Paul Petersen

One of my Monday’s Music Moves Me friends featured Shelley Fabares’ “Johnny Angel” as part of yesterday’s post, and it gave me an idea for today’s Two for Tuesday. In case you were wondering how I came up with the idea.

Remember The Donna Reed Show? It ran from 1958 to 1966 and starred Donna Reed, Carl Betz, Shelley Fabares, and Paul Petersen as the Stone family. It was really popular – I mean, we used to watch it – and was the typical Fifties family sitcom, made in the days before TV dads were idiots.

Paul Petersen was a singer of some talent, and recorded a number of songs in the early and mid Sixties, including “My Dad,” which he sang for his TV dad on an episode of the show. It’s a beautiful song, and Paul’s TV family seemed to be highly moved by it, especially his TV dad. Remember, these were the days when men didn’t show much emotion, which makes Mr. Betz’s reaction to the song so beautiful, wanting to cry, but not allowing himself to. This made its debut on the show in 1962, and was released as a single later that year, and it reached #6 on the Hot 100.

Naturally, the producers wanted to capitalize on the show’s popularity, and knowing that Paul’s records were going over big, soon turned their attention to their other teenaged star. She didn’t consider herself a singer and balked at the idea, but eventually recorded “Johnny Angel.” It also debuted on the show and was released as a single in 1962, and the non-singer, who it turned out had a rather good voice, reached #1 on the Hot 100. Take that, TV little brother!

The show can still be seen in reruns. Most recently, I saw a marathon of the episodes on the Decades channel a couple of months ago. I happened to turn it on at about 11:00 Sunday night, and before I knew it it was almnost two. Okay, the show was corny, but I liked it.

Anyway, that’s your Two for Tuesday, May 24, 2016, and I’m off for my date with the physical therapist.

8 thoughts on “Two For Tuesday: Shelley Fabares and Paul Petersen

  1. The Donna Reed Show was an iconic one, up there with Father Knows Best, My Three Sons and Ozzie and Harriet. I fired Paul Peterson! This song was special,too. I had never seen Shelley Fabares sing this. Funny, huh? ๐Ÿ™‚


  2. I had forgotten about the song “My Dad,” but I know I have heard it many times on oldies radio. I did not forget about Shelley Fabares’ “Johnny Angel.” I did forget they sang these songs on the TV show. Those good old family shows. ๐Ÿ™‚


    1. Do you remember when James Darren (known in those days as Jimmy Darren) was a special guest and ‘dated’ older sister Mary?

      Liked by 1 person

  3. The Donna Reed Show made Thursdays my favorite days of the week – because it was on Thursday nights here. You should check out this link – – and see what happened to William Paul Petersen. I admit that, as a teenager, I had a crush on him.


    1. I had seen that before. Show business has the tendency to do that with young actors, and boys seem to have a harder time than girls finding work afterwards. He went from teen heartthrob to “Paul who?” in a hurry, didn’t he? It’s a shame, but he managed to pull it together and stay mad enough that he’s been able to help others.


Comments are closed.